Affluent Labs website overhaul: design review
2026-10-30. All 15 pages (3 designs x 5 pages) were rendered in off-screen Chrome (playwright-core, throwaway profile) at 1440 px and 375 px. Screenshots and raw results are in _review/. Re-run the review with node _review/review.mjs (server on 127.0.0.1:8116).
Automated checks on every page after the fixes: no console errors or failed requests, every link resolves, no horizontal overflow at 375 px, all text and buttons at least 4.5:1 contrast (large headings at least 3:1), a visible focus ring with at least 3:1 contrast on the first 12 tab stops, nothing animating and nothing hidden when reduced motion is on, and the mobile menu opens with tap targets of 52 px.
Shared wording (content.mjs)
| Was | Now | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Stat "0: Passwords we ever need from you" | "1: Written scope agreed before any work begins" | An absolute claim the website service cannot guarantee |
| Stat "3: Services, each with a written scope" | "3: Services you can combine as you need" | Repeated the scope point |
| "usage records" (AI Policy, twice) | "a simple record of how tools are used" | Jargon |
| "Business email on your own domain" | "Business email at your own web address" | Jargon |
| "Monitoring, with a prompt reply..." | "We keep watch on your site and respond promptly..." | Plain English |
| "Let us talk about what you need." | "Let's talk about what you need." | Sounded stilted |
| Footer showed "·" and "©" | Fixed | Broken characters, introduced during this review and caught by the new mojibake check |
No prices appear anywhere.
Design 1: Editorial
What was wrong
- The dark hero contradicted the "ink and paper" idea and looked too much like Design 3.
- The header and top bar were full width, but the content used a centred column, so the left edges did not line up.
- The outcome quote was pinned to the far left edge of the window.
- "How we work" showed four items in a three-column grid, which left one orphaned item.
- On mobile, the sticky header took up 121 px, the navigation wrapped onto two lines and the tap targets were only 23 px.
- The contact form said "We have your message" but sent nothing (no backend), so enquiries were silently lost.
- The browser requested a favicon that did not exist, which produced a 404.
What I changed
- The hero is now on paper: a large serif headline, a serif lead, a red rule before the eyebrow, a red button, and a quiet proof line with em dashes. The header has a double rule underneath.
- The header and top bar now sit inside the same column as the content, and the quote is aligned with the content.
- "How we work" is a 2 x 2 grid.
- Mobile now has a Menu button that opens a full-width list with 52 px tap targets. The header is 76 px.
- The form now opens the visitor's email app with the message filled in, and the thank-you text says so honestly.
- Added an inline favicon.
Caveats: The form still relies on the visitor's email app until it is connected to a real endpoint.
Design 2: Studio
What was wrong
- There was no call to action in the hero on any page. The only one was the small header pill.
- The red service marquee repeated on every service page, where it added noise.
- The stats rule spanned the page padding, and the stats had no spacing between them on mobile.
- On mobile, the sticky header was 144 px and the navigation wrapped awkwardly.
- "Three ways we help" broke onto two lines in a half-width column.
- The favicon 404.
What I changed
- Added a red pill "Book an intro call" to the home and service heroes.
- The marquee now appears on the home page only.
- Each stat now has its own rule, and the stats have proper spacing.
- The section heading column is wider.
- Mobile now has a Menu button with a 52 px link list, and the header is 65 px. Below 520 px the header pill is hidden because the hero carries the call to action.
- Added an inline favicon.
Caveats: The marquee pauses on hover only. It stops entirely under reduced motion.
Design 3: Modern
What was wrong
- Each service card had the long audience sentence as a shouting all-caps kicker above a tiny 1.2 rem title, so the hierarchy was inverted.
- Thin diagonal "beam" lines looked like rendering faults.
- The macOS traffic-light "app window" on service pages was a gimmick that does not suit a consultancy.
- The count-up animation on single-digit stats added nothing.
- The secondary hero button read "Three ways we help", and on mobile it wrapped out of line.
- On mobile, the sticky header was 170 px with two rows of pills.
- The sections were spaced too loosely.
- The favicon 404.
What I changed
- The card kickers are now short ("01 · One-to-one coaching"), the titles are larger, and the audience sentence appears as muted text under the description.
- Removed the beams and kept the soft glow.
- The step panel header now reads "AI Policy · 4 steps", in the kicker style.
- Removed the count-up from the stats and from site.js.
- The hero buttons now read "Book an intro call" and "See our services", with a flex gap between them.
- Mobile now has a Menu button with a 52 px list, and the header is 69 px.
- Tightened the section spacing.
- Added an inline favicon.
- Kept the tasteful effects: the glass header, the animated conic border on the lead card, the soft marquee, the glow in the call-to-action panel, and the scroll reveals. All of them are off under reduced motion.
Caveats: It still reads more like a software product than an advisory firm. The rotating border uses @property, so it stays static in older browsers, which is harmless.
Design options index
Each card swatch now previews the design's actual headline style. The descriptions match what was built, including Design 1's new paper hero. The index also links to this review.
Recommendation
Design 1 (Editorial) fits best. Its calm serif-on-paper look signals an established, trustworthy advisor to non-technical business owners. Design 2 is a strong, more assertive second. Design 3 risks looking like a tech product rather than a personal consultancy.